There’s a lot of forum chatter about Big Daddy crawling issues.
I’m not going to link to any of the debates, especially one I spotted in a leading SEO forum which, in my humble opinion, contained nothing but utter b**shit. No, I’m not going to mention it.
Heh 
I guess my point is: “be careful what we believe”. If there’s something odd happening, it’s amazing the conclusions some so-called SEO experts jump to, and the speed with which they do it. Before you know it, mere conjecture becomes undisputed fact, and it’s no wonder most people don’t have a clue how to rank in Google any more.
Personally, I believe in testing. And reading research papers (pick out the pieces of data a huge search engine could actually process in a cost-effective manner). And not reading seo forums (much) 
PS: Aaron has a thoughtful post on the subject.
I couldn’t agree more Peter, but be careful, you will notice a sharp decline in your blog visitors going against the mainstream of SEO followers.
You must enjoy Bill Slawski and his SEO by The Sea, he digs deep into patents.
Agreed. Bill does dig deep – and provides some excellent analysis. I’m glad Bill takes the time to do it – saves me having to!
SEO forums, blogs etc are fine, but people have to be careful who they listen to. A lot of theories are just that – theories – and they don’t become fact simply by virtue of being repeated often.
When you ask people to prove their theories, most tend to go quiet.
[...] Peter Da Vanzo posting on V7N mentions that SEO’s often tend to draw incorrect conclusions in the forums. In his post Deep Crawls SEO Myths he makes a good point about “being careful of what we believe” because what we believe is sometimes wrong. I asked Peter to clarify. [...]
[...] Now, I recall remarking on some forum discussions about crawl issues, and the fact that many posters were jumping to some pretty wild conclusions. If you’re not getting crawl depth, site structure might well be the cause. [...]
[...] Now, I recall remarking on some forum discussions about crawl issues, and the fact that many posters were jumping to some pretty wild conclusions. If you’re not getting crawl depth, site structure might well be the cause. [...]